Walk the plank - a great idea for our pirate party! We had a Pirate swimming party and put the across the baby pool. The kids had to walk the plank without falling in the water. It was the best part of the party.
Take this idea and make a couple of coat or clothing wall hooks! "Hook Toss" game for a pirate party *Website has lots of other pirate themed party ideas. Idea centered around Jake and the Never-land pirates!
'Defuse the Bomb' for Superhero party or cannon balls for Pirate theme - fill each balloon with a small trinket (tattoo, sticker, bouncy ball, tiny cars & skateboards, etc) and each kid has to pop the balloon any way they can to get to the prize.